The number one thing that has always bugged me about theology is that it seems so easy to cheat - especially when the prevailing view is that the deeper meanings of scripture are metaphorical instead of metaphysical. I felt the same way studying English Lit - terms become purely abstract, ideas get redefined and conflated, and thoughts divorce from reality. John Bunyan is a perfect example. Allegory is label, symbolism, concept. Just think your way through whatever the trouble is and trust that God will be there with you, in the thinking.
I know Theology as a field is Philosophy focused on the Divine, which gets sub-divided into categories by restricting input - Systematic Th., Biblical Th., NT Th., Th. of Romans, Baptist Th., Etc. Then there's Pop Th., "Redneck Th." - and the broadest category of all - Personal Th. Essentially, everyone builds up their own God Logic. Some are more thoroughly justified than others and some are more consistent than others but even the most well defended theologies boil down to pure logical thinking. "Garbage in, garbage out." It's all hit or miss, often swung with a white knuckled fist, and there's almost always a twist.
So to get back to business, I've been asking myself for two years What can I say about Jesus in Nazareth? But I started this project four years ago, at which point I never expected to be fighting this battle at all. I just didn't like leaving so many Year Books so bare of material about the Lord. Isn't Jesus worth more than Tiberius? Isn't he more interesting? Shouldn't He be the focus of every Year Book, at least for a couple of paragraphs?
Over time, my own year-by-year thinking built up until I couldn't stop wondering, what the heck was He doing all during that time? Obviously, imagination is easy. Devotional reconstructions can sometimes be beautiful and inspiring. But what can we say in terms of physical real-life events that is reasonably justifiable, in terms of a faith-based historiography of the Gospels? In other words, I have been asking myself: what can we say, without cheating?
So while I haven't been formally trained in theology, I do think I know a 'hawk' from a 'handsaw'. Long time readers know my mind to some degree. I'm interested in reconstructing events for the sake of events. So if I read a scripture that clearly relates Who, What, When or Where, I'm going to consider it a factual event - whether physical or metaphysical. But if I read a scripture that says something unclear, or something that requires interpretation, I'm going to leave it totally-the-heck-alone. At least, that's the working plan at the moment.
So yes, of course, I barely know what I'm doing here. Maybe that's an advantage in some ways as well, but let's judge it after I'm done attempting it. After all, who really knows? Maybe the reason nobody has reconstructed the life of Jesus in Nazareth (as a primarily historical reconstruction, with minimal theological assumptions as necessary - or if they have please point me to it) could be because larger Theologies have always held first place for all scholars who would ever have been likely to consider the project. But there's a first time for everything, right? And I strongly suspect there are more ways of dealing with scripture than have yet to be dreamed of in our philosophies, "Horatio".
To be continued...
This is my sandbox. I keep promising to do actual scholarship.
At least this is here: "new ideas, free to good homes"
At least this is here: "new ideas, free to good homes"
NT/H Blog Archives
- ► 2012 (73)
- ► 2011 (72)
- ► 2010 (263)
- Jesus in Nazareth - Post Index So Far
- The Nazareth Synagogue - 14
- The Nazareth Synagogue - 13
- The Nazareth Synagogue - 12
- The Nazareth Synagogue - 11
- The Nazareth Synagogue - 10
- The Nazareth Synagogue - 9
- The Nazareth Synagogue - 8
- Law and Love
- The Nazareth Synagogue - 7
- The Nazareth Synagogue - 6
- Gospel Facts for Facts' Sake
- Leadership and Oversight
- Coffee Talk
- The Nazareth Synagogue - 5
- Jesus + Father, Pre-Baptism
- Matthew's Composition Process
- Lights & Fanfare
- Your Brain on Blogs
- HELP! - Synoptic Problem Research Question
- Sequence, not Harmony
- What's happened to me?
- 12 Bodyguards at the Nazareth Synagogue
- The Nazareth Synagogue - 4
- Jesus' 12 Bodyguards
- The Nazareth Synagogue - 3
- Nazareth: Legalism or Mysticism?
- Nazareth So Far...
- Leading, not Lording
- Lording it Over
- How Jewish was Galilee?
- HED on Theology
- OED on Metaphysical
- The Nazareth Synagogue - 2
- They CAN Handle the TRUTH
- The Nazareth Synagogue - 1
- NT Historical Math
- Incredible UPS!
- Stunning Ignorance
- Did Jesus Ignore Mary to Protect Her?
- Look at my Boy
- Tiger Dog
- Dealing with Nazareth - 7
- Johannine Historiography
- Nicodemus the Writer (and Gospel Source?)
- Ancient Journalism - Speeches and Sound Bytes
- Dealing with Nazareth - 6.1
- Dealing with Nazareth - 6
- The Most Challenging Miracles
- Geaux, Tiger!
- "The ____ of my Father" - House, Things or People?...
- Sometimes, I Pretend I'm This Guy
- Dealing with Nazareth - 5
- Dealing with Nazareth - 4
- In case you missed...
- Dealing with Nazareth - 3
- Dealing with Nazareth - 2
- Dealing with Nazareth - 1
- ▼ August (58)
- ► 2008 (83)
- ► 2007 (19)
On chronology, that is. By me, of course. ;) This post comes because of a paragraph I just read in which James D.G. Dunn provides a nearly ...
Is there a comprehensive list of these, anywhere? I sure can't find one online. Google keeps giving me bad apologetics sites and a Wikip...
It takes an awfully good pastor to be better than no pastor at all.
At least once in his public ministry, somewhere, Jesus said to some people: "Unless you turn around and become like little children, y...
Those who handle the Gospels most intelligently are too eager to dismiss their basic historical aspects, and those who handle the Gospels mo...
My main interest in Lysanias, tetrarch of Abilene, began in hopes of finding a comparative case study (however minuscule) to make with Hero...
Joseph, Mary and the boys (James, Joseph, Simon & Jude) moved to Capernaum with Jesus after the wedding in Cana. The Lord's sisters...
Marcus Borg wants to see the New Testament's 27 documents rearranged "based on contemporary mainstream biblical scholarship" a...
There are only two things I know of on this earth that are ever lived in or filled by the Spirit of God: our souls, and His Word. Countless ...
A famous six word short story makes a quick and easy first test case for my latest ideas. Legend says Ernest Hemingway wrote this to settle ...